What’s the Difference Between Pumpkin and Sweet Potato Pie? (UNBIASED COMPARISON)

Whether youre planning a Thanksgiving feast or just looking for something sweet and delicious, you may be wondering which type of pie to make pumpkin or sweet potato? While both pies are delicious, there are some important differences between them that may make one better suited for certain occasions.

In this unbiased comparison, well explore the unique elements of each type of pie and explain which one would best fit your needs.

Lets dive in!

Difference Between Pumpkin And Sweet Potato Pie?

Pumpkin and sweet potato pies are two popular and delicious pies that are often served around the holidays.

Although they look similar, these two pies are actually quite distinct.

The main difference between them is the main ingredient used.

Pumpkin pie is made from pureed pumpkin, while sweet potato pie is made from mashed sweet potatoes.

Pumpkin is a type of winter squash with a mild, sweet flavor, while sweet potatoes are root vegetables with a savory, subtly sweet flavor.

The flavor profiles of these two pies also vary.

Pumpkin pie has a classic, sweet taste, often spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves.

Sweet potato pie, however, can be enhanced with spices like nutmeg, cinnamon, and ginger, as well as brown sugar and even marshmallows.

The texture of these two pies also differs.

Pumpkin pie is usually creamy and smooth, while sweet potato pie is usually denser and more moist.

Finally, the toppings on these two pies can be different.

Pumpkin pies are often topped with whipped cream or a streusel topping, while sweet potato pies are usually topped with meringue or marshmallows.

In conclusion, while pumpkin and sweet potato pies may look similar, they are actually quite distinct.

Pumpkin pies are typically spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves, have a smooth and creamy texture, and are usually topped with whipped cream.

Sweet potato pies are usually spiced with nutmeg, cinnamon, and ginger, have a denser and moister texture, and are usually topped with meringue or marshmallows.

Does Pumpkin Pie And Sweet Potato Pie Taste The Same?

No, pumpkin and sweet potato pies don’t taste the same. Both are classic, beloved Thanksgiving desserts, but they offer very different flavors. Pumpkin pie combines spices such as cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger with pumpkin puree, resulting in a warm and comforting taste that is best served with whipped cream. Sweet potato pie, on the other hand, utilizes a combination of cinnamon, nutmeg, and brown sugar to create a more complex flavor than pumpkin pie. Additionally, the two pies differ in texture: pumpkin pie is usually denser than sweet potato pie, which often has a pudding-like consistency. If you’re looking for something unique, try making a pumpkin-sweet potato hybrid pie for the best of both worlds!

Which One Is Better Pumpkin Or Sweet Potato Pie?

The debate between pumpkin and sweet potato pie has been ongoing for some time and is unlikely to be resolved soon.

Both pies have distinct flavors and textures, making it difficult to decide which one is better.

It all comes down to personal preference.

Pumpkin pie is a classic option with a spiced flavor and a creamy, smooth texture.

The sweetness of the pumpkin pairs nicely with the spices and adding a layer of whipped cream or ice cream on top enhances the flavor.

On the other hand, sweet potato pie has an earthy flavor that pairs well with its naturally sweet potatoes.

Its texture is slightly crunchy on the outside and soft, custard-like inside.

Topping with marshmallows or a crumbly crust adds a sweet and crunchy layer.

Ultimately, it is up to the individual to decide which flavor and texture they prefer.

Pumpkin pie is ideal for those who appreciate a classic taste, while sweet potato pie is perfect for those looking for something more unique.

Which Is Better For You Pumpkin Pie Or Sweet Potato Pie?

The debate between pumpkin pie and sweet potato pie is a close one.

Both pies offer a range of nutrients, such as Vitamin A and C, calcium, and iron.

However, there are key differences in their nutritional value that can make one a better choice for you than the other.

When it comes to nutritional value, pumpkin pie has the edge.

It is packed with Vitamin A and C, as well as fiber, calcium, and iron.

Additionally, it has a lower calorie count than sweet potato pie; one slice of pumpkin pie contains about 247 calories and 10.7 grams of sugar, while a slice of sweet potato pie can have up to 353 calories and 20.3 grams of sugar.

Though pumpkin pie comes out ahead in terms of calories, sweet potato pie has its own advantages.

It is higher in fiber than pumpkin pie, with one slice containing 4.1 grams compared to the latters 3.2 grams.

Sweet potato pie also has more potassium, magnesium, and zinc, which are all important minerals for healthy body functioning.

In the end, it all comes down to personal preference.

Both pies are delicious and nutritious, so it ultimately depends on your dietary needs and goals.

If you’re looking for something low in calories and sugar, go for pumpkin pie.

If you are looking for something higher in fiber and minerals, sweet potato pie may be the better option.

Can I Substitute Sweet Potato For Pumpkin In Pie?

Yes, you can substitute sweet potatoes for pumpkin in a pie! Sweet potatoes are creamy and full of vitamins and minerals, making them a great and healthy alternative to pumpkin puree.

To make sweet potato puree, simply bake the potatoes until they are soft and then mash or puree them until they are smooth.

You can also add spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, or allspice to enhance the flavor.

When substituting sweet potatoes in a pumpkin pie recipe, make sure to use the same amount of sweet potato puree as pumpkin puree.

This will help ensure the texture and flavor of the pie are similar.

Sweet potatoes tend to make the pie a bit sweeter than pumpkin, so if you’d like to reduce the sweetness, add a bit of lemon or lime juice to the recipe.

Overall, sweet potatoes can be a great substitute for pumpkin in a pie.

Not only is it a healthier option, but it can also add a unique flavor to the recipe.

Just remember to adjust the sweetness and texture as needed when substituting sweet potatoes for pumpkin.

Is Sweet Potato Pie Lighter Or Darker Than Pumpkin Pie?

When it comes to comparing sweet potato pie and pumpkin pie, it is hard to say which one is lighter or darker as it will depend on the recipe and ingredients used.

However, if we compare a traditional sweet potato pie to a traditional pumpkin pie, it will usually appear darker.

This is mainly due to the fact that sweet potatoes are darker in color than pumpkins, and this will be reflected in the pie.

When making sweet potato pie, the potatoes are boiled, mashed and added to the filling.

This will give the pie a darker color than pumpkin pie, as the mashed potatoes are a richer and darker color than pumpkin.

On the other hand, pumpkin pie is usually cooked and strained, which removes some of the color and texture, making it lighter in color than sweet potato pie.

In addition, sweet potato pie is usually made with spices such as cinnamon, nutmeg and allspice, which have a darker shade than the spices used in pumpkin pie, such as ginger, cinnamon and cloves.

Therefore, the spices used in sweet potato pie will contribute to its darker color.

In conclusion, each sweet potato and pumpkin pie is unique and the color may vary depending on the recipe and ingredients used.

However, typically, sweet potato pie will be darker than pumpkin pie.

What Is Sweeter Pumpkin Or Sweet Potato?

When it comes to the debate of pumpkin versus sweet potato, it all comes down to personal preference.

Both offer a sweet and delicious flavor that makes them great additions to dishes ranging from pies and muffins to soups and stews.

Pumpkin is noticeably sweeter than sweet potato due to its higher natural sugar content.

Some find that pumpkin has a slightly more intense flavor, while sweet potato has a more mellow and subtle taste.

However, when it comes to nutrition, sweet potato takes the lead, as it contains more fiber, calcium and iron than pumpkin.

So, which one do you prefer? If you’re looking for a sweeter option, then pumpkin is the way to go.

But if you’re looking for a healthier option with more nutrients, then sweet potato is the better choice.

Either way, both are delicious and sure to be a hit in any dish!

What Does A Sweet Potato Pie Taste Like?

A sweet potato pie is a delightful combination of sweet and savory flavors.

It has the sweetness of a classic dessert but is complemented with the earthy taste of sweet potatoes.

The texture of a sweet potato pie is similar to that of a pecan pie, boasting a crunchy crust and a soft, custard-like filling.

The sweet potatoes give the pie a unique flavor and a creamy texture.

The spices used to make a sweet potato pie can vary.

Common spices used to enhance the flavor include cinnamon, nutmeg, and vanilla, which add warmth and depth.

Optional ingredients, like raisins, chopped nuts, or marshmallows, can also be added to the pie.

All of these ingredients come together to make a truly delicious and unique flavor.

The flavor of a sweet potato pie is both comforting and enjoyable.

The sweetness of the sugar and the earthiness of the sweet potato, combined with the spices, give the pie a complex yet balanced flavor.

To balance the sweetness, a pinch of salt can be added.

Whether served warm or cold, the flavors of a sweet potato pie blend together harmoniously, creating an inviting and delicious dessert.

What Is Similar To Sweet Potato Pie?

Sweet potato pie is a classic southern dessert that has been a part of many families for generations.

Made with sweet potatoes, sugar, butter, spices, eggs, and cream, this delicious treat is baked inside a flaky pastry shell, creating a luscious and savory dessert that is perfect for any occasion.

Other desserts with a similar flavor profile are pumpkin pie and pecan pie.

The former is made with pumpkin puree, sugar, butter, spices, eggs, and cream, with the main difference being the graham cracker crust instead of a pastry one.

Pecan pie, on the other hand, is rich and nutty, with a combination of butter, sugar, eggs, and pecans.

Both fillings are then placed in a pastry shell and baked to a golden, bubbly finish.

The sweet potato biscuit is also a great option.

It is a mix of sweet potatoes, sugar, butter, and spices that is baked in a flaky biscuit crust.

This is a popular breakfast item at many establishments, and a great way to begin the day.

No matter your pick, these desserts are sure to make everyone smile! Sweet potato pie, pumpkin pie, pecan pie, and sweet potato biscuits are all delicious options that are sure to be a hit.

What Is The Best Substitute For Pumpkin For Pie?

Looking for a healthier alternative to traditional pumpkin pie? Sweet potatoes and squash are great substitutes! Sweet potatoes are creamy and provide a slightly sweet flavor, while squash has a slightly nuttier flavor and is more fibrous.

Both can be used to create a delicious and nutritious pie.

To make a substitute for pumpkin pie, start with either a sweet potato or squash puree.

Peel, cube, and steam the vegetable until soft, then mash or puree in a blender or food processor until smooth.

Use the puree in your favorite pumpkin pie recipe, or add spices and flavorings to make it unique.

If you don’t have time to make a puree, you can also use canned sweet potatoes or squash.

Just make sure to choose unsweetened varieties for the most natural flavor.

Drain the liquid and use the solids like you would use pumpkin puree.

No matter what substitute you choose, making a pumpkin pie with sweet potatoes or squash is sure to be a delicious and healthier alternative.


What Pumpkin Tastes Like Sweet Potato?

Pumpkins and sweet potatoes may look similar, but they have completely different tastes.

Pumpkins have a mild, earthy flavor that makes them ideal for soups, pies, and stews.

Sweet potatoes, on the other hand, have a sweeter and more complex flavor that pairs well with spices such as cinnamon, nutmeg, and allspice.

Although pumpkin may seem to have a slight sweetness to the untrained palate, it is nowhere near as sweet as a sweet potato.

The main difference between the two vegetables lies in their texture; pumpkins are firmer and denser, while sweet potatoes are softer and fluffier.

Although pumpkin and sweet potato may have some similarities in flavor, they are still distinct and unique in their own way.

To make the most of each vegetable, pair them with complementary ingredients that bring out the best in each.

For instance, pumpkin goes well with savory ingredients like onions, garlic, and sage, while sweet potatoes work best with sweet ingredients such as honey, brown sugar, and maple syrup.

In conclusion, pumpkin does not taste like sweet potato.

The two vegetables are similar in color and shape, but they have very different flavors and textures.

Pumpkin has a mild and earthy flavor that pairs well with savory ingredients, while sweet potatoes are much sweeter and work best with sweet ingredients.

Final Thoughts

In the end, both sweet potato and pumpkin pies are delicious and have their own unique flavors.

While pumpkin pie has a classic, nostalgic taste and is great for colder months, sweet potato pie is a warm and comforting treat perfect for any season.

Whether you’re looking for a traditional Thanksgiving dessert or a sweet snack to share with friends, you can’t go wrong with either of these classic pies.

So, go ahead and get baking!


James is a passionate vegetable expert who loves to share his expertise with others. He has studied vegetables for many years and is continually learning new things about them. He is knowledgeable about the different varieties of vegetables, their nutritional values, and how to cook them. He also knows a lot about gardening and growing vegetables.

Recent Posts